Is your grant-making strategy still fit for purpose?

Across the charitable sector, organisations continue to grapple with rising costs, increased demand for services and ongoing funding uncertainty. While these pressures are most visible among charities delivering frontline services, they also present important challenges for grant makers, including foundations, trusts, corporate funders and public sector bodies.

As the operating environment becomes more complex, many grant makers are rethinking how they allocate, manage and monitor funding. At the heart of these discussions is the need to balance the evolving needs of grantees with funders’ own governance, risk management and accountability responsibilities. While recognising the increasingly challenging environment in which recipients operate, grant makers must still ensure that funding is used effectively and in line with its intended purpose.

Achieving this balance is rarely straightforward. So, what should grant makers be considering?

Balancing trust and accountability

Given the pressures charities are already under, efforts to reduce administrative burdens and introduce greater flexibility are often welcomed. Many funders are simplifying application processes, offering unrestricted funding and reducing reporting requirements to enable charities to focus on delivery rather than administration.

The growth of trust-based philanthropy has rightly challenged some traditional funding practices. However, trust should not be misunderstood as the absence of oversight. Rather, it requires grant makers to rethink how they gain assurance, moving away from transactional monitoring towards a more proportionate understanding of organisational health, risk and impact.

Grant makers still need to understand how funding is being used, whether projects are progressing as expected and whether recipients have the capacity to deliver effectively. The key is ensuring that oversight is proportionate to the risks involved.

A small grant awarded to an established organisation may require relatively light-touch monitoring. By contrast, a substantial multi-year commitment, funding a complex programme or supporting a new recipient, may warrant more detailed scrutiny and ongoing engagement. Applying exactly the same processes to every grant may create consistency, but it does not always result in effective oversight.

Effective grant assurance is rarely about conducting more checks. Instead, it is about applying the right level of scrutiny in the right places. Higher-risk, higher-value or more complex grants may require enhanced due diligence, periodic financial reviews or independent assurance. Lower-risk grants may require little more than regular communication and proportionate monitoring.

Recognising the early warning signs

Even where appropriate controls are in place, challenges can emerge during the lifetime of a grant.

Financial pressures, recruitment difficulties, governance challenges and operational disruption can all affect an organisation’s ability to deliver intended outcomes. Identifying these risks early allows grant makers to respond constructively before issues become more significant.

Potential warning signs may include deteriorating cash reserves, recurring operating deficits, delays in project delivery, significant staff turnover, governance instability or an over-reliance on a small number of income sources. While none of these factors automatically indicate a serious problem, they may signal that additional support, dialogue or assurance is required.

Regular and open communication can be just as valuable as formal reporting. Strong relationships often encourage recipients to raise concerns at an earlier stage, enabling funders to understand challenges and explore solutions collaboratively.

Depending on the nature and risk profile of the grant, this may be complemented by progress reviews, site visits, financial assessments or independent assurance work designed to provide additional confidence over how funds are being managed and deployed.

Looking beyond the funding decision

Good grant making extends well beyond the initial funding decision.

Trustees must ensure that grant-making activities align with their organisation’s charitable objectives, financial position and appetite for risk. This includes understanding how funding decisions are made, managing potential conflicts of interest and ensuring appropriate controls are operating effectively.

Financial sustainability also remains an important consideration. While multi-year grants can provide valuable certainty for recipients, they can also reduce flexibility and limit the resources available for future commitments. Funders must balance the need for long-term support with the need to remain responsive to changing circumstances.

Increasingly, boards should also consider the resilience of their overall funding portfolio. Are funding decisions aligned with strategic priorities? Is risk concentrated within particular sectors, geographies or delivery models? Are existing monitoring arrangements generating meaningful insight, or simply collecting information?

Trustees should ask themselves some important questions:

  • Which grants present the greatest risks?
  • How confident are we that funds are being used appropriately?
  • Do our monitoring and assurance arrangements reflect the level of risk involved?
  • Are we receiving information that genuinely supports decision-making?
  • If a significant project failed, could we demonstrate that appropriate oversight had been exercised?
  • Where next for grant makers?

Grant making has never been a one-size-fits-all exercise, and the increasingly complex environment in which charities now operate only reinforces the need for a tailored approach.

In a more uncertain operating environment, effective grant making is increasingly defined by the quality of judgement applied throughout the funding lifecycle. The challenge for grant makers is not choosing between trust and accountability but designing approaches that successfully deliver both.

If you’re reviewing your grant-making strategy, due diligence processes or monitoring arrangements, our team can help. We work with funders across the sector to strengthen governance, develop proportionate assurance frameworks and provide independent insight that gives trustees confidence their funding is delivering the intended outcomes.

Senior Risk and Assurance Manager